retirementtaxeshow-to

Should You Increase 401(k) Withdrawals if Expenses Rise? A Tax-Savvy Decision Framework

UUnknown

2026-02-24

10 min read

Practical, tax‑aware steps to decide whether to raise 401(k)/IRA withdrawals when living costs stay high—covers taxes, RMDs, sequence‑of‑returns, and Roth tactics.

When living costs stay high, should you take bigger 401(k) or IRA withdrawals? A tax‑savvy decision framework for 2026

Hook: Your bills didn’t drop when you retired—and now you’re facing a choice: increase withdrawals to keep pace with expenses, or hold the line and hope markets cooperate. Both choices carry costs: tax surprises, faster depletion risk, and the dreaded sequence‑of‑returns hit. This guide gives a practical, tax‑aware framework to decide whether, how much, and when to increase 401(k)/IRA withdrawals.

Topline answer — the short version

If higher withdrawals are needed to cover essential life expenses, increase withdrawals—but do so strategically, not reflexively. Use a stepwise approach: (1) prioritize cashflow and emergency buffers, (2) run a tax‑impact projection for the next 3–5 years, (3) evaluate sequence‑of‑returns risk and hedge it with buckets or partial annuitization, and (4) consider Roth conversions and QCDs for tax smoothing. In other words: cover essentials first, then optimize for taxes and longevity.

Why this matters more in 2026

Several trends through late 2025 and early 2026 make withdrawal planning more complex:

Persistently higher baseline living costs for many retirees compared with pre‑2020 norms.
Evolving RMD rules after SECURE Act changes made earlier in the decade—RMD ages and required calculations now affect strategy timing.
Greater focus on Medicare IRMAA and Social Security tax interactions as retirement income rises.
Interest rates and bond yields that have recovered since the early 2020s, giving more low‑risk income options but also changing the tradeoffs for withdrawals.

Core concepts you must understand before increasing withdrawals

1) Marginal tax impact

Each extra dollar you take from a traditional 401(k) or IRA is taxed as ordinary income. That can push you into a higher marginal bracket, raise Social Security taxable amounts, and trigger Medicare IRMAA surcharges. Always model after‑tax income, not just gross withdrawals.

2) Sequence of returns risk

When you withdraw during a market downturn, you lock in losses. Larger withdrawals early in retirement amplify this risk. That’s why withdrawal timing should account for current market valuations and your remaining time horizon.

3) Withdrawal sequencing

Your tax and longevity outcomes depend on which buckets you spend first:

Taxable accounts (tax‑loss harvesting opportunities)
Tax‑deferred accounts (401(k), traditional IRA)
Tax‑free accounts (Roth IRA)

Optimal sequence varies by household, especially when Social Security, pensions, and Medicare phases are considered.

Step‑by‑step decision framework

Use this repeatable process when you’re considering a withdrawal increase.

Step 1 — Separate essentials from wants

Identify the portion of increased spending that is non‑negotiable (mortgage, medical, food, utilities) versus discretionary (travel, dining out). If the raise is for essentials, prioritize maintaining that cashflow even if taxes rise slightly.

Step 2 — Build a 12–24 month cash buffer

Before dialing up permanent withdrawals, create or top up a short‑term buffer (6–24 months of essentials). With high market volatility, a cash cushion lets you avoid selling assets during downturns.

Step 3 — Run a 3‑5 year tax projection

Model these items for the next 3–5 years under two scenarios: current withdrawals and proposed increased withdrawals. Include:

Ordinary income from 401(k/IRA withdrawals
Social Security taxable percentage (provisional income calculations)
Medicare IRMAA thresholds and estimated surcharges
Capital gains from taxable account sales

Tip: run marginal tax‑rate buckets (for example, how much you can withdraw within a given tax bracket) rather than only total taxes.

Step 4 — Consider Roth conversions and timing

If you expect higher taxable withdrawals long‑term, consider converting some traditional assets to a Roth while you are in a lower bracket. Conversions increase current taxes but reduce future RMDs and tax exposure. In 2026, this is especially powerful if you have a low‑income stretch or expect higher brackets later.

Step 5 — Apply sequence‑risk hedges

Options include:

Bucket strategy: keep 1–3 years of cash/short bonds for withdrawals and invest longer‑term assets for growth.
Partial annuitization: buying a deferred or immediate annuity for a portion of predictable needs reduces withdrawal pressure.
Dynamic withdrawal rules: use percent‑of‑portfolio approaches or guardrails tied to market performance rather than a fixed dollar amount.

Higher withdrawals could raise provisional income and the portion of Social Security that's taxable. In some cases, delaying Social Security to a later age reduces the need to withdraw from tax‑deferred accounts at high marginal rates.

Step 7 — Evaluate Medicare IRMAA impact

A seemingly small increase in taxable income can trigger higher Medicare Part B/D premiums under IRMAA. When modeling withdrawal increases, include estimated IRMAA surcharges (they can add thousands of dollars annually).

Concrete example: Married couple, balancing increased expenses

Illustrative case study (numbers rounded):

Age: 67 and 65
Assets: $800k traditional 401(k)/IRA, $150k taxable, $80k Roth
Sources: $24k Social Security (combined), no pension
Goal: cover a $12k/year rise in essential expenses (mortgage and healthcare outlays)

Option A — Increase annual withdrawals from IRA by $12k:

Gross extra withdrawal: $12k
Marginal tax: depends on other income, but could push taxable income into a higher bracket; also increases provisional income for Social Security and potential IRMAA.
Risk: If markets decline in the next 3 years, the withdrawn dollars reduce long‑term portfolio sustainability.

Option B — Liquidity and partial tax optimization:

Use $12k from taxable account sale (or part cash buffer) for 12–24 months of increased costs to avoid extra tax‑deferred withdrawals right away.
Simultaneously run a Roth conversion plan to use any low‑income window to shift $10k–$25k/year into Roth — smoothing taxes across years.

In our example, Option B preserves tax‑deferred savings during volatile markets and uses taxable assets first—often a superior sequencing choice when taxable accounts have low cost basis or can supply needed cash with limited capital gains.

Rules of thumb and practical thresholds

Emergency buffer: keep 6–24 months of essential spending in short‑term liquid assets before increasing permanent withdrawals.
Marginal tax guardrail: avoid withdrawals that push you up a full tax bracket unless the money is for essentials; instead, withdraw up to the bracket cap and reassess.
Sequence risk buffer: if you face large early withdrawals during poor market returns, consider cash reserves or a short‑term bond ladder to bridge 2–5 years.
Roth conversion window: prioritize conversions in years where taxable income (before conversion) is unusually low, including early retirement years when Social Security is deferred.

Special strategies to consider

Qualified Charitable Distributions (QCDs)

If you’re over the RMD age and charitably inclined, QCDs let you send up to $100k directly from IRA to charity (rules apply) without including that amount in taxable income—helpful if higher withdrawals would raise taxes or IRMAA.

Partial annuitization and deferred income annuities

Buying a low‑cost lifetime inflow for a portion of essential expenses can reduce the need for volatile withdrawals. In 2026, improved longevity annuity products are more competitive because higher bond yields have improved payout rates.

Tax‑aware harvesting from taxable accounts

Sell low‑basis stocks selectively, offset gains with losses, and use the net proceeds to cover bridge spending rather than tapping 401(k)/IRA. Coordinate this with capital gains tax planning.

When increasing withdrawals is the right answer

You need the money for essential, ongoing costs and have no alternative income sources.
Your portfolio has a long time horizon and you can adjust spending if markets underperform.
You’ve modeled the tax impact and the after‑tax income still supports your household needs.

When to avoid larger withdrawals

If the need is temporary and you have taxable assets or other temporary income sources.
If taking more will move you into significantly higher tax brackets or trigger IRMAA penalties.
If your portfolio recently suffered losses and you lack cash reserves—taking more now magnifies sequence‑of‑returns damage.

Practical checklist — do this in the next 30 days

Run a 3‑5 year after‑tax income projection including proposed withdrawal increases.
Inventory liquid assets and set or confirm a 6–24 month essential spending buffer.
Check RMD timing and amounts (SECURE Act changes affect your schedule).
Estimate IRMAA and Social Security tax effects from the higher withdrawals.
If converting to Roth, project the tax bill and confirm it doesn’t trigger costly surcharges or bracket jumps.
Consider taking smaller, staged increases (e.g., +25% now, revisit in 6 months) rather than a single permanent jump.
Talk to a CPA and certified financial planner who specialize in retiree income and tax planning.

Common objections and quick rebuttals

Objection: "I must take more now because my mortgage/medical bills won’t wait."

Rebuttal: Prioritize essentials and combine short‑term liquidity tactics (use taxable account cash, reverse mortgage options if appropriate, or a home equity line) while modeling the long‑term tax drag of permanent higher withdrawals.

Objection: "I’m worried markets will crash—should I cut withdrawals immediately?"

Rebuttal: Cutting spending is sensible if you can adjust lifestyle. But sudden large cuts can hurt quality of life. Create a layered plan: buffer cash to cover 12–24 months, reduce discretionary spending, and maintain structural hedges like bucketing or partial annuity purchases.

Tools and resources to use now

Tax projection worksheet that links withdrawals to provisional income and Medicare IRMAA.
Retirement withdrawal simulator with sequence‑of‑returns stress testing.
Roth conversion calculator that shows current tax vs. future RMD savings.
Consultation with a CPA who can run specific tax scenarios and an independent fiduciary‑adviser who can stress‑test your portfolio.

Key point: Increasing 401(k) or IRA withdrawals to meet persistent expenses is often necessary — but must be treated as a tax and sequence‑of‑returns problem, not just an income line item.

Final checklist before you pull the trigger

Do you have a 6–24 month cash cushion? If no -> build buffer first.
Have you run a multi‑year tax projection including IRMAA and Social Security effects? If no -> run projection.
Have you considered short‑term taxable account withdrawals instead of tax‑deferred ones? If yes -> compare tax outcomes.
Have you evaluated Roth conversions to smooth future taxable exposure? If appropriate -> plan staged conversions.
Have you stress‑tested withdrawals under poor market returns (sequence‑of‑returns)? If no -> stress test and consider hedges.

Where retirees commonly go wrong

Underestimating the impact of small withdrawals on Medicare premiums and Social Security taxation.
Failing to set aside a market‑downturn buffer and then selling assets at depressed prices.
Making large, irreversible Roth conversions without checking short‑term IRMAA or cash needs.

Next‑level strategies for advisors and DIY investors

For investors with complex tax situations or larger portfolios, advanced tactics include laddered Roth conversions aligned with bracket edges, pairing partial immediate annuities with inflation riders, and integrating municipal bond income to reduce federal taxable income. Work with tax pros to implement—these moves are powerful but require precision.

Closing — a practical parting roadmap

Rising living costs in retirement do not automatically mean you must increase 401(k) or IRA withdrawals permanently. Treat the decision as a short‑term cashflow problem and a long‑term tax and sequence‑of‑returns problem. Start with a temporary buffer, run tax scenarios, use taxable assets first where possible, and use Roth conversions strategically. When you must increase withdrawals for essentials, do so in measured steps with tax and market stress tests in hand.

Call to action: Don’t guess—plan. Run a 3‑year after‑tax withdrawal projection today and get a short call with a CPA or fiduciary to map one staged path forward. If you want, start by making an inventory of your accounts and estimated essential spending; bring that to your advisor and use the checklist above as your meeting agenda.

Unknown

Contributor

Senior editor and content strategist. Writing about technology, design, and the future of digital media. Follow along for deep dives into the industry's moving parts.